Best Smart Scales for Fitness Tracking: GadgetScout Shortlist

Published 8 Sept 2026

Our current shortlist of smart scales for fitness tracking, among the products covered by GadgetScout: Withings Body Smart and RENPHO Elis 1, without a universal ranking.

Among the smart scales currently covered by GadgetScout for fitness tracking, two models stand out: the Withings Body Smart and the RENPHO Elis 1. This shortlist helps you choose between them.

Quick picks: choose the Withings Body Smart if the Withings app ecosystem, Wi-Fi syncing and multi-user tracking matter most; choose the RENPHO Elis 1 if a straightforward Bluetooth scale with app history is enough.

This shortlist covers only the products GadgetScout currently covers; it does not claim to include every option available. It is built only from documented sources: the published product sheets and the manufacturer-announced specs. We have not run independent tests and we make no body-fat accuracy claims. Current pricing can change, so check both before deciding.

• •Withings Body Smart: a Wi-Fi + Bluetooth smart scale syncing to the Withings app, with body-composition estimates via bioelectrical impedance analysis and multi-user, long-term trend tracking
• •RENPHO Elis 1: a Bluetooth-connected smart scale using the RENPHO companion app, tracking weight and multiple body metrics over time, with capacity up to 400 lb / 180 kg

• •Withings Body Smart: a polished app ecosystem with multi-user support and long-term trend tracking, with Wi-Fi syncing alongside Bluetooth
• •RENPHO Elis 1: simple to integrate into a daily routine, with app history that makes it easy to observe trends

• •Withings Body Smart: body-composition numbers are estimates, not clinical measurements; the app and a Withings account are required for the full feature set; check phone compatibility and multi-user support
• •RENPHO Elis 1: body-composition values are impedance-derived estimates, not medical measurements; results can vary with hydration, time of day and measurement conditions — measure consistently; check the manufacturer sheet for capacity and accuracy
• •Both: neither scale is a substitute for professional medical evaluation

WHO IT FITS

The Withings Body Smart for shoppers who want a polished app experience, multi-user support and long-term trend tracking in the Withings ecosystem. The RENPHO Elis 1 for people who want a connected scale for weight and body-metric trends at home, without over-interpreting a single reading.

BUYING DECISION

Neither is universally better: the Withings Body Smart leans on the app ecosystem and Wi-Fi syncing, the RENPHO Elis 1 on straightforward Bluetooth tracking with app history. Choose according to how you track your data, then check phone compatibility and the current prices on the official sheets. For a direct head-to-head between the two, our dedicated comparison covers the differences in detail.